MoonShine Modern Supper Club - Millburn, New Jersey

Lilli-Ana M.

Came to Moonshine for a birthday brunch with 5 girls. It was all our first time there and it will NOT be our last. From the food to the service everything was amazinggg. The mac n cheese was delishhh, burger delishhh, fries delishhh, drinks delishhhh. Our server who i believe was named Mustafa was the absolute best server i’ve ever had ! He was extremely patient and very attentive. Couldn’t have had a better experience. We will ask for him as our server every time going forward ! Thank you again Moonshine staff for an amazing time !

Kan H.

My first Moonshine experience was okay. We entered restaurant on Thursday at 7 pm. I saw few people at bar but no one at tables.
Service was great but foods wasn’t hot at all … except desserts.

Tasha T. D.

I had high hopes for this place, but unfortunately, my experience was disappointing. I ordered the Spicy Vegan Ramen and the 24-hour Braised Short Rib, and neither dish met expectations. The ramen lacked flavor was not spicy and they were overcooked while the short rib and the mashed potatoes were undercooked . Given the price and the wait time, I expected much better quality. I won’t be returning. We were also charged an acceptance fee to eat there 3%..

Peachlynn M.

All I can say is exceptional! This was our first time here and I cannot express how pleased we are with our visit. Food was good but the service and atmosphere was great! To here upbeat current music makes the world of difference. And returning to bachata made me feel right at home. The expedited noticed our table was wobbly and immediately fixed it. I didn’t get the expediters name but he was more than accommodating. He was very attentive and made us feel so welcomed! We were late for our musical and he offered to have us come back to enjoy the dessert after the show. We live an hour away but will definitely be making the trip. Even considered having our bridal shower here! Run don’t walk!

Sophie C.

I came in earlier this week late night and was greeted by Jesse the bartender he was above and beyond taking my extremely abnormal and complicated drink order to the next level and by the second drink, he knew exactly what I wanted Making it even better than the last, my fiancé also had a wonderful time and took his recommendation for an IPA and loved it. We were shown the happy hour of the week. That is such a wonderful deal will definitely be back! Shout out to Jesse who made the whole experience worth it. Great date night!

M M.

I stumbled upon this hidden gem during a snowstorm, and what an incredible find it turned out to be! From the moment I walked in, I was welcomed with warm hospitality, and despite the weather, the restaurant remained open—showing true dedication to its customers.

Jessie, our bartender, truly elevated the experience. His attentiveness and friendly demeanor made the evening even more enjoyable. The DJ set the perfect vibe, spinning old-school hip-hop that created an intimate yet lively atmosphere, even with a smaller crowd due to the storm. The fact that they stayed open and kept the energy high speaks volumes about their consistency and appreciation for their guests. A special touch was when they went out of their way to sing happy birthday to my boyfriend—such a thoughtful and memorable gesture!

Now, let’s talk about the food—absolutely phenomenal! The octopus appetizer was cooked to perfection, and the olives that accompanied it were hands down the best I’ve ever had. For my entrée, I had the harper steak, and I can confidently say it was one of the most flavorful steaks I’ve had in years. Every bite was a 10/10, and the pricing was more than reasonable for the quality of the meal.

I’m not from the area, but this experience left such an impression that I’ve already shared it on social media, and I’ll definitely be returning. A huge thank you to the team for making this such a memorable night—I can’t recommend this place enough!

Camille H.

I reserved the Loft for a special brunch with close family and friends from NY, NJ, PA and Maryland in March 2025. Victor was extremely patient with planning and was available to talk, text or email, which made me very comfortable. He allowed extra time for my event planner, Mimi Planned Events, to setup. He provided extra tables that we needed. The loft has a modern look with a balcony and it was private and clean. The service, wait staff, bartender, food and music was superb. The food was delicious, the portions were surprisingly large and the drink package was great! My guests were so impressed with the event space and the service. Some guests plan on coming back to the restaurant. Overall, it was such a pleasant experience. Thank you Victor and staff for accommodating such a large party!

Ernestra M. S.

Wonderful experience! I am so impressed with all the service. We had one of our family members’ 45th birthday there. It was 17 of us, and we all had an amazing time: great food, great service, great atmosphere, and they played the song we requested. Five stars! We definitely put our boots on the ground.